Avatar's Ashes of the Academy, Explained (Spoilers)

Mai went back to school. On purpose.

Avatar's Ashes of the Academy, Explained (Spoilers)

Spoiler warning. This breakdown covers the whole graphic novel, ending included.

Our trip through the Avatar comics set between the show and Korra has reached the last of the three standalone Fire Nation books. Last time we covered The Bounty Hunter and the Tea Brewer, and this one sends Zuko's little sister to school and gives Mai a job she never asked for (teaching, of all things).

Dark Horse released Ashes of the Academy on March 25, 2025, as an 80-page graphic novel (Dark Horse). Faith Erin Hicks wrote it, Peter Wartman drew it and Adele Matera colored it, the same team behind the Toph, Azula and Iroh books, with Michael Dante DiMartino and Bryan Konietzko credited alongside Hicks.

Where does Ashes of the Academy fit in the timeline?

It takes place after the war and after The Search, the comic where Zuko found his mother, Ursa, and learned he had a half-sister named Kiyi, GamingTrend explains. Kiyi is now old enough to start at the Royal Fire Academy for Girls, the school that shaped Azula.

You don't need to have read The Search to follow along. If you know that Zuko is Fire Lord and that Mai can hit anything with a knife, you're ready.

Why is Ursa worried about the Royal Fire Academy?

The book opens with Ursa and Zuko at the academy gates. Ursa admits she regrets sending Azula there, because she thinks the school brought out the worst in her daughter, and she isn't sure Kiyi belongs there either. Zuko promises to protect the new students.

Ursa tells Zuko she regrets sending Azula to the Royal Fire Academy for Girls in Ashes of the Academy
Ursa has some history with this school. Art by Peter Wartman with colors by Adele Matera (Dark Horse Comics).

Zuko has also made two big changes. The academy is now open to every girl in the Fire Nation, whatever her family, and after a century of propaganda its lessons now teach the truth about the war, according to GamingTrend. (Ursa jokes that a few parents won't be thrilled.)

Who is Headmistress Shihan?

She runs the academy, and she doesn't like Zuko's plan at all. In Dark Horse's preview pages, she tells him she has "reservations" about the new lessons and that the school "must not coddle its students." Zuko answers that he wants a future very different from the one his father wanted.

When Zuko wonders out loud whether she's the right person for the job, Shihan reminds him that the families who send their daughters to her school are the most powerful people in the Fire Nation. She also keeps a portrait of the old headmistress on her wall, next to honors from Fire Lords Ozai and Sozin.

Why does Zuko make Mai a teacher?

Zuko wants someone he trusts inside the school, so he tells Shihan he's bringing in Governor Ukano's daughter, Mai. Shihan remembers Mai as "not the most motivated student," but agrees because Mai comes from the right family.

Zuko tells Headmistress Shihan he is bringing Governor Ukano's daughter Mai to the academy as a new teacher in Ashes of the Academy
Zuko has a hire in mind. Art by Peter Wartman with colors by Adele Matera (Dark Horse Comics).

Mai's reaction is exactly what you'd expect. She can't believe anyone would pick "the girl who hates people" to teach the Fire Nation's brattiest kids, while her mother insists she has a sensitive heart under all that gloom. Once Mai is in the classroom, she replaces lessons that glorified domination and violence with honest ones, Wikipedia's summary notes.

What happens to Kiyi at the academy?

Trouble starts on day one. Kiyi's best friend, Lihua, comes from a common family, and an older noble girl calls her a "peasant" and knocks her down with a blast of fire. Kiyi fires right back to protect her friend.

Kiyi firebends at an older noble student to protect her friend Lihua in Ashes of the Academy
Kiyi did not come to make friends with bullies. Art by Peter Wartman with colors by Adele Matera (Dark Horse Comics).

From there, the fights between noble and commoner students keep growing, including arguments over Agni Kai duels. Shihan handles them badly at first because she's attached to the old traditions, according to Wikipedia.

What do the Azula flashbacks show?

The book cuts back to Mai's own first days at the academy. Her father pushed her to befriend Azula for political reasons, and Mai finally won Azula over by showing off her knife throwing, a fan review on Zuko-Always-Lies points out. Young Azula is cruel from her very first day, so Ursa's fears look pretty reasonable.

How does Ashes of the Academy end?

Azula's old loyalists are still out there, including Dai Li agents who stay loyal to her years later, and they become a real threat at the school. Mai, Kiyi and Lihua work together to protect the other students from bullying, from rewritten history and from the Dai Li, according to Wikipedia.

In the end, Shihan accepts that the school has to change, and Mai realizes she actually likes teaching. With help from Zuko and a surprise visit from Ty Lee, who ignores Mai's personal space in classic Ty Lee fashion, the academy starts to value truth and kindness over power.

Is Ashes of the Academy worth reading?

My read is yes. Putting Mai in front of a classroom is the funniest idea in the whole Fire and Family trio, and it works because her dry humor hides how much she cares. GamingTrend gave it an 87 and called it "fun" and "thoughtful," and it has a 4.22 rating from about 1,600 readers on Goodreads.

The three books also fit together nicely. Azula's story was about someone who refuses to change, Iroh's was about people choosing to change, and this one is about forcing an entire school to change. The downside is the usual one for these 80-page books. GamingTrend found the ending a little rushed, and Shihan's change of heart comes fast.

As an Amazon Associate, Church of Nerds earns from qualifying purchases. Buying through the Amazon links in this post supports the site at no extra cost to you.

If you want to read it, it's available as a standalone book, and it's also collected in the Fire and Family Treasury with Azula in the Spirit Temple and The Bounty Hunter and the Tea Brewer. Next on our list is the newest standalone, Jet: Rebels and Rhinos.

Would you want Mai as your teacher? Tell us in the comments.

Header image is the cover of Ashes of the Academy from Dark Horse Comics. In-article panels are from Dark Horse's official preview, art by Peter Wartman with colors by Adele Matera.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Like it here? Tell Google.

Pick Church of Nerds as a preferred source and you'll see more of our stories in Google's Top Stories.

Add us on Google
1 of 4

Merch We'd Actually Wear